World Insights: Fallacies and truths about U.S. slander against China on Ukraine issue 聚焦

Xinhua   2023-03-27 16:31:04

PeoplewalkpastadamagedbuildinginMariupol,Feb.18,2023.(PhotobyVictor/Xinhua)

-TheUnitedStates,thetrueinitiatoroftheUkrainecrisis,hasbeenfuelingtensionsbetweenRussiaandUkrainebyprovidingmilitaryassistancetothelatter,andhasbeenreapinghugeprofitsfromtheconflict.


【资料图】

-China,incontrast,alwaysstandsonthesideofpeaceandhasplayedaconstructiveroleinadvancingthepoliticalsettlementoftheUkrainecrisis.

BEIJING,March26(Xinhua)--SincetheescalationoftheUkrainecrisis,theUnitedStateshaschurnedoutfallaciestodiscreditChinaonarangeofrelatedissuesandmisleadtheinternationalcommunity.

Infact,theUnitedStates,thetrueinitiatorofthiscrisis,hasbeenfuelingtensionsbetweenRussiaandUkrainebyprovidingmilitaryassistancetothelatter,andhasbeenreapinghugeprofitsfromtheconflict.China,incontrast,alwaysstandsonthesideofpeaceandhasplayedaconstructiveroleinadvancingthepoliticalsettlementoftheUkrainecrisis.

U.S.slandersarelistedbelowwithanaccountoffactstorestoretruthsandofferaholisticperspectiveontheissue.

ThisphototakenonAug.23,2022showsthedemolitionsiteofadamagedbuildinginMariupol.(PhotobyVictor/Xinhua)

FALLACY1:CitingcommentsofsomeseniorU.S.officialsorreportsfromWesternintelligenceagencies,someU.S.mediaaccusedChinaofhavingpriorknowledgeofRussia"s"specialmilitaryoperation"againstUkraine.

TRUTH:ChinahasrepeatedlyrefutedtheclaimsthatChinaknewabout,acquiescedtoortacitlysupportedRussia"smilitaryaction,whicharepurelydisinformationintendedtoshiftblametoandslingmudatChina.

Thereweremorethan6,000ChinesecitizensinUkraineandChinaisthebiggesttradingpartnerofbothUkraineandRussia,aswellasthelargestimporterofcrudeoilandnaturalgasintheworld.AconflictbetweenRussiaandUkrainedoesnogoodforChina.Chinawouldhavetrieditsbesttopreventtheconflicthaditknownaboutitinadvance.

Ontheotherhand,Russiaisasovereigncountrythatindependentlyweighs,decidesandimplementsitsforeignpolicybasedonitsownstrategyandinterests.ThereisnoneedtoseekChina"sconsentbeforehand.

ItisworthmentioningthattheChina-Russiarelationshipfeaturesnon-alignment,non-confrontationandnon-targetingofanythirdparty.ItdiffersfromthepracticesoftheUnitedStatesandseveralotherWesterncountriesthatsticktotheColdWarmentalityofdrawingideologicallinesandadoptingafriend-or-foedichotomy,formingso-called"alliances"and"cliques,"andpursuingblocpoliticsthatcreateconfrontationanddivision.

ThisphototakenonFeb.3,2023showstheWhiteHouseinWashington,D.C.,theUnitedStates.(Xinhua/LiuJie)

FALLACY2:TheUnitedStatesaccusedChinaofamplifyingKremlin"s"propagandaandconspiracytheories"aboutUkraine,spreading"falseinformation"includingthat"theUnitedStatesisconductingbio-militaryactivitiesinUkraine,""theUnitedStatesandNATOcausedtheUkrainecrisis"and"theUnitedStates,especiallythemilitary-industrialcomplex,isthebiggestbeneficiaryoftheUkrainecrisis."

TRUTH:China"spositionontheUkraineissueisaboveboard,objectiveandfair.RelevantreportsbytheChinesemediawereallbasedonfacts.

First,onU.S.bio-militaryactivitiesinUkraine,theAgreementBetweentheDepartmentofDefenseoftheUnitedStatesofAmericaandtheMinistryofHealthofUkraineConcerningCooperationintheAreaofPreventionofProliferationofTechnology,PathogensandExpertisethatcouldbeUsedintheDevelopmentofBiologicalWeaponssignedbythetwocountriesonAug.29,2005,clearlystipulatesthattheU.S.DepartmentofDefenserepresentativesshallhavetherighttoparticipateinallrelatedactivitiesatfacilitiesinUkraine;alldangerouspathogensinUkraineshallbestoredatdesignatedlaboratories;UkraineshallsharewiththeU.S.datageneratedbytherelevantsurveillancenetwork,transfertotheU.S.siderequestedcopiesofdangerouspathogenstrains,andwithholdinformationdesignatedbytheU.S.sideas"sensitive"frompublicdisclosure.

InNovember2021,theUnitedStatesadmittedthatithad26biolabsinUkraineinitsworkingdocumentsubmittedtothemeetingoftheStatePartiestotheBiologicalWeaponsConvention.AccordingtoafactsheetreleasedbytheU.S.DepartmentofDefenseinMarch2022,theUnitedStateswassupporting46facilitiesinUkraine.

OnMarch8,2022,U.S.UnderSecretaryofStateforPoliticalAffairsVictoriaNulandadmittedataSenatehearingthat"Ukrainehasbiologicalresearchfacilities,which,infact,wearenowquiteconcernedRussianforcesmaybeseekingtogaincontrolof,soweareworkingwiththeUkrainiansonhowtheycanpreventanyofthoseresearchmaterialsfromfallingintothehandsofRussianforcesshouldtheyapproach."

U.S.mediaalsocriticizedthattheU.S.governmentliedaboutthesecretbiologicallaboratoriesinUkraineandconcealedtherealpurposeofsupportingtheselaboratoriesfromthepublic.

Accordingtopublicinformation,theUnitedStateshasconductedmorebio-militaryactivitiesthananyothercountryintheworld.Itisalsotheonlycountrythathasusedbiologicalandchemicalweaponsinmultiplewars,andtheonlycountrythatopposestheestablishmentofamultilateralverificationmechanismfortheBiologicalWeaponsConvention,apublicstandheldbytheUnitedStatesformorethantwodecades.

Second,theUnitedStatesandNATOcausedtheUkrainecrisis.In1990,thenU.S.SecretaryofStateJamesBaker,duringhismeetingwithleadersoftheSovietUnion,promisedclearlythatNATOwouldmove"notoneincheastward."

AdocumentdisclosedbytheNationalArchivesoftheUnitedKingdomshowedthattheU.S.representativehadpromisedinnegotiationsbackthenthatNATOshouldnotexpandtotheeasteitherformallyorunofficially.

However,underthedominationoftheUnitedStates,NATOhasexpandedeastwardfivetimessince1999,increaseditsmembershipfrom16to30,andadvancedmorethan1,000kmeastwardrightuptoRussianborders,creatingaC-shapedencirclementoftheBlackSea.

RussiahasforyearsproposeddialoguewiththeUnitedStatesonanewEuropeansecurityarchitecture,onlytobeignoredbytheU.S.side.In2021,RussiaofferedtonegotiateandsignasecurityguaranteesagreementwithNATO,butwasstonewalledbytheUnitedStatesandNATO.

TheUnitedStatesandNATO,whilefullyawareofRussia"ssecurityconcerns,strengthenedmilitaryassistancetoUkraineandhelpedittrainmilitarypersonnel.AccordingtoU.S.mediareports,formerU.S.officialssaidthattheUnitedStateshasprovidedalargeamountofadvancedmilitarytrainingforUkrainianelitetroopsandspecialoperationforces.Since2015,theCIAhasconductedaseriesofintensivemilitarytraininginUkraineinvolvingguns,landnavigationandcamouflagetechniques.Theprogram,whichbeganunderPresidentBarackObama,wasexpandedunderPresidentDonaldTrumpandfurtherenlargedundertheJoeBidenadministration.

JohnMearsheimer,aU.S.politicalscientist,pointedoutthat"theWestbearsprimaryresponsibilityforwhatishappeningtoday."Hesaid,"HereI"mtalkingabouttheWest,wetookastick,andwepokethebearintheeye...andthatbearisprobablygoingtofightback,andthat"sexactlywhat"shappeninghere."

FormerU.S.CongresswomanTulsiGabbardsaidinaninterviewifBidensimplypromisednottoincludeUkraineintoNATO,thecurrentRussia-Ukraineconflictwouldhavebeenprevented.

Third,theU.S.militaryindustrialcomplexhasindeedrakedinhugeprofitssincetheRussia-Ukraineconflictbegan.SincetensionssurroundingUkrainestartedtoriseinOctober2021,sharepricesofU.S.militarygiantshavekeptshootingup.JamesTaiclet,chiefexecutiveofLockheedMartin,saidthatcompetitionbetweenmajorpowerswouldbringmorebusinesstothecompany.

ThetotalvalueofStateDepartment-authorizedgovernment-to-governmentforeignmilitarysaleswas51.9billionU.S.dollarsinfiscal2022,up49.1percentfromthepreviousfiscalyear"s34.8billiondollars,accordingtodatareleasedbytheDepartmentofState,whichattributedtheincreasemainlytoU.S.militarysupportforUkraineduringthelatter"sconflictwithRussia.

TheUnitedStateshasalsousedtheUkrainecrisistopushitsalliestoimposetougheconomicsanctionsandevenanenergyembargoonRussia.U.S.energycompaniescashedinonthecrisisandsoldtoEuropealargeamountofoilandgasatahighprice.

AccordingtoKpler,adataandanalyticsfirm,theEUimported38.86milliontonsofLNGin2022fromtheUnitedStates,whichaccountedforroughly41percentoftheEU"stotalLNGimportsandincreasedby23.59milliontonscomparedwith2021,ayear-on-yearriseof154percent.

TheUnitedStatesbecametheworld"slargestLNGexporterinthefirsthalfof2022,up12percentfromthesecondhalfof2021,largelydrivenbysurgingdemandinEurope,datafromtheU.S.EnergyInformationAdministrationshowed.

FrenchPresidentEmmanuelMacron,inOctober2022,criticizedtheU.S.practiceofenjoyinglowenergypricesathomewhileexportingatrecordhighpricestoreapsuperprofitsfromthegeopoliticalconflict.SpeakingtoAmericanandNorwegianentrepreneurs,hesaid,"Yousupplyuswithenergyandgas,butonethingthatcan"tgoonfortoolongisuspayingfourtimesmorethanthepriceyouselltoyourindustry."

PeopleinspecttheaftermathofshellingofthecitymarketinDonetsk,Dec.12,2022.(PhotobyVictor/Xinhua)

FALLACY3:TheUnitedStatesaccusedChinaofnotcondemningorsanctioningRussia,falselyclaimedthatChinahasnointentiontoparticipateinanyformofdiplomaticresolutionoftheUkraineissue,slanderedChina"sstrategyasunconstructiveandattemptedtoportrayChinaasbeingirresponsible.

TRUTH:China"spositionontheUkraineissuehasbeenobjectiveandjust.Chinaalwaysstandsonthesideofpeaceandhasplayedaconstructiveroleinadvancingthepoliticalsettlementofthecrisis.ChinesePresidentXiJinpingoutlinedfourprinciples,calledforjointeffortsinfourareasandsharedthreeobservationsonUkraine.Henotedperceptivelythatconflictsandwarsproducenowinner;thereisnosimplesolutiontoacomplexissue;andconfrontationbetweenmajorcountriesmustbeavoided.Thispointstherightwayforwardforthedeescalationoftensionsandpoliticalsettlementofthecrisis.

OnFeb.18,2023,WangYi,directoroftheOfficeoftheForeignAffairsCommissionoftheCommunistPartyofChina(CPC)CentralCommittee,answeredaquestionconcerningChina"sstanceatthe59thMunichSecurityConference.HesaidtheUkrainecrisisisnotwhatChinawouldliketosee,andChinaisalsoconcernedthattheRussia-Ukraineconflictmightbeescalatedandprotracted.

Chinaisnotapartydirectlyinvolved,butdoesnotchoosetobeabystanderoraddfueltothefire,andstilllessexploitsthecrisis,Wangsaid,notingthateverythingChinahasbeendoingontheUkraineissueistofacilitatepeacetalks.

TheUnitedStatesistheonewhostartedtheUkrainecrisisandthebiggestfactorfuelingit,andhaskeptsendingheavyandassaultweaponstoUkraine,whichhasonlyprolongedandintensifiedtheconflict.Theinternationalcommunityisfullyawarewhoiscallingfordialogueandstrivingforpeace,andwhoisfanningtheflamesandstokingconfrontation.

FALLACY4:TheUnitedStateshasrepeatedlyaccusedChinaofproviding"non-lethalassistance"toRussiathroughChinese-fundedenterprises,andclaimedthatChinabegantoconsiderproviding"lethalassistance"toRussia.

TRUTH:Theso-calledintelligencebytheUnitedStatesisnothingmorethangroundlessrumorsandslander.U.S.officialsthemselveshaveacknowledgedthatthereisnoindicationthatChinahasdecidedtosupplyRussiawithweapons,butmeanwhiletheysaidtheybelievethepossibilitystillexists.

TheChina-Russiarelationshipisbuiltonthebasisofnon-alignment,non-confrontationandnon-targetingofthirdcountries,whichiswithinthesovereignrightofanytwoindependentstates.Chinaengagesinnormaleconomicandtradecooperationwithallcountries,includingRussia,onthebasisofequalityandmutualbenefit.China-Russiacooperationiscompletelyaboveboard.Itservesthepurposeofdeliveringbenefitstobothpeoplesandpromotingglobalgrowth.Itshallbefreefromdisruptionorcoercionfromanythirdparty.

Chinaalwayshandlesexportofmilitaryitemsinaprudentandresponsiblemannerandregulatesexportofdual-usearticlesinaccordancewithrelevantlawsandregulations.Atthesametime,Chinaisconsistentlyopposedtounilateralsanctionsandlong-armjurisdictionwithneitherbasisininternationallawnorUnitedNationsSecurityCouncilmandate.China"sconsistentpositionandpracticestandinsharpcontrastwiththeactsoftheU.S.thatappliesdoublestandardsonarmssalesandkeepaddingfueltothefireontheUkrainecrisis.

BytheendofFebruary2023,theUnitedStateshadprovidedUkrainewithover32billionU.S.dollarsworthofmilitaryaid,includinglargequantitiesofadvancedarmament.TheUnitedStateshasbeenpouringweaponsintoonesideoftheconflict,thusprolongingthefightandmakingpeaceelusive,whilespreadingdisinformationthatChinawouldsupplyweaponstoRussiaandsanctioningChinesecompaniesunderthatpretext.Thisisout-and-outhegemonismanddoublestandard,andabsolutehypocrisy.

Protestersgatherduringtheanti-wardemonstrationinWashington,D.C.,theUnitedStates,March18,2023.(Xinhua/LiuJie)

FALLACY5:TheUnitedStatesclaimsitisnowfacingtwoglobalpowers--ChinaandRussia,eachwithsignificantmilitarycapabilities,andbothintendingtofundamentallychangethecurrent"rules-basedorder,"anditisconcernedbecauseChinaandRussiashareavision.TheUnitedStateshasalsorepeatedlyaccusedChinaofposingthe"mostseriouslong-termchallenge"totheinternationalorder.

TRUTH:Chinaalwayspursuesanationaldefensepolicythatisdefensiveinnatureandadherestothemilitarystrategicguidelineofactivedefense.Sinceitsfounding,thePeople"sRepublicofChinahasneverinvadedothercountries,neverengagedinproxywars,neversoughtspheresofinfluence,norparticipatedinanymilitaryblocconfrontation.

ThegrowthofChina"smilitarystrengthisagrowthoftheforceforpeaceintheworld.ChinahasbeencommittedtotheUN-centeredinternationalsystemandtheinternationalorderunderpinnedbyinternationallaw.Chinahasbeenupholdingtruemultilateralism,workingforamulti-polarworldandgreaterdemocracyininternationalrelations,andmakingglobalgovernancemorejustandequitable.

WhenitcomestoChina-Russiarelationship,thetwocountriesalwaysfollowthepathofpartnershipoverallianceanddialogueoverconfrontation,andgrowanewtypeofmajor-countryrelationsfeaturingmutualrespect,peacefulcoexistenceandwin-wincooperation.ThewayChinaandRussiadevelopthestrategicpartnershipofcoordinationwillbenefitthetwopeoplesandtheworldatlarge.Itisentirelydifferentfromwhatcertaincountrieshavebeendoing,includingholdingontotheColdWarmentality,gangingupwithothercountries,formingcliquesandstokingblocconfrontation,andengaginginhegemonic,domineeringandbullyingpractices.

TheUnitedStateshaswantonlyaccusedChinaofattemptingtochangethe"rules-basedinternationalorder,"butitisactualyworriedthattheU.S."hegemonicorder"isaffected,andthatthe"rulesofthegang"setupandpackagedbytheUnitedStatesasinternationalrulestocontainandsuppressothercountriesarechallengedandrejected.

TheUnitedStatesistheNo.1warmongerintheworld.Itwasnotatwarforonly16yearsthroughoutits240-plusyearsofhistoryandaccountedforabout80percentofallpost-WorldWarII(WWII)armedconflicts.

TheUnitedStatesisalsotheNo.1violatorofsovereigntyandinterfererintheinternalaffairsofothercountries.Accordingtoreports,sincetheendofWWII,ithassoughttosubvertmorethan50foreigngovernments,grosslyinterferedinelectionsinatleast30countriesandattemptedtoassassinateover50foreignleaders.

ThecountryisalsotheNo.1sourceofantagonismandblocconfrontation.TheU.S.-ledNATOisresponsibleforwarsonAfghanistan,IraqandSyriathatkilledmorethan900,000peopleandcreated37millionrefugees.IthasalsomadetheEurasiacontinentalessstableplace.TheimpactofU.S.-initiatedQUADandAUKUSonAsia-Pacificsecurityandstabilityalsocallsforvigilance.

Protestersgatherduringtheanti-wardemonstrationinWashington,D.C.,theUnitedStates,March18,2023.(Xinhua/LiuJie)

FALLACY6:TheUnitedStateshasappliedtheprincipleofsovereigntyselectively.Ithasrepeatedlyhypedupthefallacythat"Chinabearsresponsibility"byfalselyclaimingthat"China"spositionontheUkraineissuecontradictsChina"slong-standingprincipleofrespectingstatesovereigntyandterritorialintegrity"andthat"ChinahastheobligationtourgeRussiatomakeconcessionsontheUkraineissue."

TRUTH:China"spositionontheUkraineissueisconsistentandstaysunchanged.China"sremarksareinlinewithitspositionthatregionalhotspotissuesshouldberesolvedthroughdialogueandconsultation.Chinaalwaysupholdsobjectivityandfairness,standsforpeaceandjustice,decidesitspositionbasedonthemeritsofthematterconcerned,andbelievesthatallcountriesshouldsettleinternationaldisputesinapeacefulwayinaccordancewiththepurposesandprinciplesoftheUNCharter.

ThefirstarticleofChina"spositiononthepoliticalsettlementoftheUkrainecrisisisaboutrespectingthesovereigntyofallcountries:"Universallyrecognizedinternationallaw,includingthepurposesandprinciplesoftheUNCharter,mustbestrictlyobserved.Thesovereignty,independenceandterritorialintegrityofallcountriesmustbeeffectivelyupheld.Allcountries,bigorsmall,strongorweak,richorpoor,areequalmembersoftheinternationalcommunity.Allpartiesshouldjointlyupholdthebasicnormsgoverninginternationalrelationsanddefendinternationalfairnessandjustice.Equalanduniformapplicationofinternationallawshouldbepromoted,whiledoublestandardsmustberejected."

TheUnitedStatessaysthere"sdesireforpeacetoprevail,yetithaswagedwarsandstokedconfrontationaroundtheworld.TheUnitedStatessaysit"simportanttorespectandupholdtheinternationalorder,yetithasslappedmassiveunilateralillegalsanctionsandputitsdomesticlawsabovetheinternationallaw.TheUnitedStatessayscompetitionmustbefair,yetithasbeencrackingdownonforeigncompaniesbyusingallkindsofstateapparatusanddefyinginternationaltraderules.Itisclearwhoshouldbeartheresponsibilityforobstructingworldpeaceanddevelopment.